The New Prisoner Series

This show, although is American seems to have on other boards gone over a lot of their heads. The original made a LOT of references to the notion of freedom and choice. This series gives some answers the original didn’t. For me, I think satisfactorily.
In short watching this series you will be invited to ask:
- To make a utopia, sacrifices must be made and do we agree the means justifies the end without tragedy?
- We can make choices against others but are we sure they will be correct when we don’t really know what we’re winning?
- Is it better to give up? Is surrendering the right choice if we are to welcome a new better age? If so, at what cost?
- What will we do for self sacrifice?
- If given freedom to make a world better, what MUST I do to achieve it and at what cost?
- Who is really controlling us, ourselves or the big powers?
There is a rather bizarre twist, people are sent to The Village (we are lead against their will) to be cured of psychological pains. Doesn’t it sound good to be living in shall we say the real world cured, but your hurt psyche is imprisoned in another layer of consciousness? Those who rebel in the Prisoner world are dealt with severely. But who says anyone gets actually killed if all your being is a shared consciousness and you’ll just be SHUT off from the shared sub consciousness? This is proved from one of the main protagonists who dies in Prisoner world and in the real world is fine!
Of course, the end sounds good, but its manipulation. We can also ask to what end is this being used for. The show doesn’t ask that and I think probably better not to. It leaves too many questions about control open to debate. This series makes the point on personal freedom comes with tragic choices and is more a debate on ethics than escape from the bad guy and find out why. This show tells you more or less why…. but what happens if you agree with the principles of the former? When does a benign Caeser turn into a vicious dictator? For this reason I give it the HUGE thumbs up! I think it’s a great journey into how GRAND great inventions can turn into man’s worst nightmare, if the tech falls into the wrong hands!
There are some big plot holes and the technology of how it’d work in actuality. How come people can share consciousness and interact in Prisoner world? How did they get there in the first place?
We are lead to believe that there’s a lot of mental-ism between 2 and 6 IN the Prisoner world. Like any devil, 2 gives ALL the clues away, but of course with the flash forwards (or not) the viewer is confused.
People believe are sent to this world where there’s a “Derren Brown” thought/mind control added with a bit of “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind” mind control thrown in for good measure. I can take that leap of faith as is normal in any other matrix kind of world! But people interacting… this part I’ve not yet figured out in the plot!
Some people have said the characters are miscast. I’d say there’s a FEW lame parts, with 6 screaming at the gate “I’ll get you” etc… You’re more intrigued than tense throughout the shows but by episode 5 it’s already tying things together. In the final episode you’re given what actually happens, it’s a forced treatment at night and you’re living in 2 places at once. The pain of the mind is sent to Prisoner world to be conformed. This then has a positive change on the body living in the normal world. I think a very novel concept!
I’d say the filming, cast performance, direction and scripting is on bar with that of “Lost”. This is a VERY adventurous mini series.
If you’re expecting an original concept of 17 episodes of let’s face it a very spaced-out but excellent source material with the legendary 2 vs 6 battle of wits, then this will NOT be your show. There are a few technology to psychology parts that are not explained in the show, but with 6 episodes, it’s better left out and why complicate it.
If you’re expecting LONG plot curves this isn’t your show. With BSG and Lost having 6 series x 13 episodes (more or less), but you’ve condensed the major mind-thriller parts to 6 episodes, I think it’s a GRAND achievement on bar with Miike’s MPD Psycho. I found this show VERY stimulating and probably one of the most best recent remakes since BSG.